The 2025 Academy Awards Best Picture race is shaping up to be one of the most competitive in recent years, especially after the Screen Actors Guild Awards. Spanning across multiple genres and storytelling styles, this year’s ten nominees are all strong contenders for Hollywood’s most prestigious honor.

While critical acclaim and box office performance play a huge role in shaping a film’s Oscar chances, IMDb ratings offer a glimpse into audience reception. Here’s how the nominees stack up, ranked from highest to lowest based on IMDb scores.

1. I'm Still Here – IMDb: 8.7

Topping the list is I'm Still Here, a deeply emotional drama that has struck a chord with audiences. Its powerful performances and thought-provoking narrative have made it a frontrunner for Best Picture.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Unparalleled emotional depth
• Powerful lead performances
• Resonates deeply with viewers and critics alike

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor

2. Dune: Part Two – IMDb: 8.5

Denis Villeneuve’s epic sci-fi sequel has been widely praised for its stunning visuals, strong performances, and faithful adaptation of Frank Herbert’s classic novel. Already a box office juggernaut, Dune: Part Two remains a serious contender in this year’s Oscars.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Jaw-dropping cinematography & visual effects
• Exceptional storytelling and world-building
• Critical and commercial success

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Cinematography, Best Visual Effects

3. The Brutalist – IMDb: 7.7

Brady Corbet’s architectural drama has captivated audiences with its intense storytelling and unique visual style. Starring Adrien Brody, this film explores the struggles of an immigrant architect trying to make his mark in post-war America.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Unconventional storytelling
• Strong character study
• Tied with Anora in IMDb rating, but leads in Best Actor race

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Actor (Adrien Brody), Best Original Screenplay

4. Anora – IMDb: 7.7

Sean Baker’s latest film, Anora, continues his streak of sharp social commentary mixed with deeply personal storytelling. The film follows a sex worker navigating life’s struggles, and Mikey Madison's performance has been widely praised.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Sean Baker’s signature raw storytelling
• Strong lead performance
• Realistic and engaging portrayal of modern life

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Actress (Mikey Madison)

5. Wicked – IMDb: 7.6

The much-anticipated film adaptation of the Broadway hit Wicked has delivered on expectations, with Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo leading the way. The film beautifully translates the magic of the stage to the big screen.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Strong fan following
• Captivating musical performances
• Successful transition from Broadway to Hollywood

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Supporting Actress (Cynthia Erivo)

6. A Complete Unknown – IMDb: 7.6

James Mangold’s Bob Dylan biopic brings the folk icon’s story to life with an intimate and engaging narrative. The film humanizes Dylan’s journey, making it a standout in this year’s nominees.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Strong performances
• Deeply engaging storytelling
• Captures the essence of Dylan’s legacy

Oscar Buzz: Best Actor, Best Adapted Screenplay

7. Conclave – IMDb: 7.4

A political thriller set in the Vatican, Conclave explores the intense secrecy of papal elections. Packed with mystery and tension, it appeals to those who love dialogue-driven films.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Unique premise and execution
• Strong writing and direction
• High rewatchability

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Adapted Screenplay

8. The Substance – IMDb: 7.3

A psychological horror film with eerie themes and unsettling visuals, The Substance has built a dedicated fanbase despite its niche appeal. Demi Moore's performance has been hailed as one of her best.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Fresh and unique horror storytelling
• Strong lead performance
• Psychological depth

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Actress (Demi Moore)

9. Nickel Boys – IMDb: 7.1

Based on Colson Whitehead’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, Nickel Boys is a powerful exploration of systemic racism and injustice. Though its IMDb rating is lower than some contenders, its social relevance and emotional impact cannot be ignored.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Strong source material
• Emotional and hard-hitting narrative
• Powerful performances

Oscar Buzz: Best Picture, Best Adapted Screenplay

10. Emilia Perez – IMDb: 5.5

Jacques Audiard’s Emilia Perez is the lowest-rated nominee on IMDb, with a mixed reception from audiences. While some have praised its unique storytelling, others have found it divisive.

Controversy Alert:

• Lead actress Karla Sofia Gascón has faced backlash for past racist remarks, affecting the film’s reception.
• However, Zoe Saldana’s performance remains a highlight, making her a strong contender for Best Supporting Actress.

Why it’s a strong contender?

• Unconventional narrative
• Strong supporting performances

Oscar Buzz: Best Supporting Actress (Zoe Saldana)

Who’s Leading the Race?

With I'm Still Here (8.7) and Dune: Part Two (8.5) leading IMDb ratings, they emerge as top contenders for Best Picture. However, other films like The Brutalist, Anora, and Wicked could shake up the race depending on Academy voter preferences.